- Elon Musk spoke out mainly against the Trump administration’s huge tax and spending bill, which he called a ‘disgusting abomination’ instead of a sign of careful financial management.
- Musk’s resignation expressed his concern that the administration had lost interest in making significant reforms.
- Modi’s measures have included a careful effort to get rid of old and outdated regulations, improving the way services are provided to citizens.
- The difference in results shows that transforming the way governments function greatly depends on strong leadership, organised plans, and always serving the public interest.
For a long time, many global organisations have been interested in how visionary leadership and effective reform in the government work together. With Elon Musk’s acceptance of a role in the Trump administration and subsequent resignation, issues related to the country’s administrative system have drawn attention. Unlike the significant changes introduced by Prime Minister Modi in India, Musk’s reasons for leaving made it clear he had no faith in Trump’s administrative reforms. This article looks at the reasons behind Musk’s criticism of Trump, comparing it to the highly effective governance style the Indian Prime Minister has developed in India.
Elon Musk expressed disappointment with the Trump Administration.
Many thought that Elon Musk’s inclusion in the Trump administration could make a major difference during Trump’s presidency because of his achievements in technology and business. As an advisor to the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), Musk was supposed to introduce his technology-focused thinking to the American government. Still, his time in the administration brought much frustration, which eventually turned to disappointment.
Elon Musk spoke out mainly against the Trump administration’s huge tax and spending bill, which he called a “disgusting abomination” instead of a sign of careful financial management. According to him, the bill represented the government’s overall lack of action on waste, inefficiency, and financial problems. Rather than making government work more efficiently, the law included a lot of “pork-barrel” money, which was meant for projects that benefited a few politicians instead of helping everyone. Musk stressed that such spending would hurt the country’s budget and place extra debt on future generations.
Therefore, Musk’s resignation expressed his concern that the administration had lost interest in making significant reforms. The move pointed out that technical solutions work better when real political will is present and when addressing deeply rooted bureaucracies is possible.
Modi’s Innovative Changes in Running the Government
In contrast to the situation in the United States, India under Prime Minister Modi has been praised for its bold and successful changes in government. Modi started making significant changes in India’s administration after he was sworn in in 2014, based on transparent, accountable, and empowering principles.
Modi’s measures have included a careful effort to get rid of old and outdated regulations. Almost 2,000 archaic practices and procedures were done away with to speed up government work and improve the way services were given to citizens. At the same time, requiring gazetted officers to attest documents was removed, simplifying processes and showing that authorities had greater trust in people.
Also, one of the main changes introduced by the Modi government was eliminating the requirement for interviews for lower-level government jobs. The goal of this program was to keep things more open, reduce the chances of corruption, and, instead of appointing through personal ties, hire people based on their abilities. Moreover, the government launched a sanitation and cleanliness campaign that reached the entire nation and became a major concern for their system of governance. Officials managed their excess equipment skillfully, which paid off in extra income and reclaimed office spaces, leading to a better-organised government.
Modi’s way of reforming government included work for efficiency as well as for development that is inclusive. When the government improved infrastructure in the North East, it made clear its intention to promote equal growth across the country. The work done in this regard has won admiration domestically as well as internationally.
Comparative Analysis: Divergent Paths to Reform
Studying the difference in governance reform during this time between the United States and India helps explain how administrations change. Musk’s departure from the Trump administration may suggest that technology cannot fix problems without strong leadership from the political front. Even with all his accomplishments and efforts to save money, Musk could not circumvent the influence of special interests and the priorities of politicians who tried to solve present-day problems at the expense of future ones.
In this respect, Modi has governed India as a strong leader, ready to challenge the usual approaches. He managed to succeed in his reforms because of a strong plan, reliable ways to apply his changes, and continuous attention to outcomes over empty words. Modi made it clear that better management in government is possible if there is enough political will and attention to serving people.
Musk’s action shows how complicated it can be to improve government in the present era. The fact that Modi has successfully pushed for major changes is obvious when you see major critiques of the United States. The difference in results shows that transforming the way governments function greatly depends on strong leadership, organised plans, and always serving the public interest. Modernisation and new demands from citizens are considered important topics globally, and the lessons learned are still relevant for both those in charge and those hoping to improve.
References:
- Musk urges Americans to tell lawmakers to ‘kill the bill’: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0j76djzgpvo
- What Elon Musk said in criticism of the Trump Administration- One Big Beautiful bill that many claim behind his abrupt exit: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/technology/tech-news/what-elon-musk-said-in-criticism-of-trump-administrations-one-big-beautiful-bill-that-many-claim-behind-his-abrupt-exit/articleshow/121493053.cms
- Modi Govt’s governance reforms included scrapping of nearly 2,000 obsolete rules, says Dr Jitendra Singh on the eve of Good Governance Day: https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2087662
Parag is pursuing his master’s at the Jindal School of International Affairs. Views expressed are the author’s own.
Aayush Pal 
Piyush Anand 
Archita Gaur